Fordele: Beautiful house, great staff and location. Nice balance of friendliness and leaving you on your own.
Ulemper: Very hot-was asked to turn off AC in room each time we left which we adhered to but took a long time to re-cool the room. Good coffee for 2 days but then only Keurig -ugh -please no Keurig!
Fordele: Super friendly and helpful staff, great breakfast, fantastic location.
Fordele: Very high quality decor and furnishings. Very friendly and helpful. Great breakfast. Lovely Evie- resident dog. Great location .
Ulemper: That we had to leave.
Fordele: The location is excellent, on a quiet street but a pleasant walk -across the golf course- from the historical, pretty town. A 5 minute quiet walk from the beach. The B&B is perfect, very nice ...
Ulemper: No complaints at all, just it says check in time is 3.30. Maybe make that a bit earlier? Then again, we showed up at 2 PM and our room was ready.
Fordele: Interior perfect, exterior somewhat plain but a cool, cool place with just an infinitely great vibe.
Ulemper: Had to lug luggagage across the meadow from the parking and over the carpets in the narrow corridor. travel light and you will enjoy it more.
Fordele: Definately a gem! Wonderful property, beautiful room, super comfy bed, with an eye on the details. We were given a very warm welcome by Beth and we instantly felt at home. Delicious breakfast! We ...
Fordele: It was clean
Ulemper: The place
Fordele: Place is immaculate, with fun friendly staff. Breakfast was great. Atmosphere was terrific
Fordele: The room was very comfortable and the staff and owner were amazing. The design was very nice.
Ulemper: That's a tough one. I really couldn't argue against anything. We were the only people there for two of our three nights.
Fordele: My husband and I recently stayed here to celebrate our second wedding anniversary. We had nver been to shelter island before and we're eager to check it out. We enjoyed staying st this Quaint B&...
Ulemper: We could hear other guests in the hall as they came and went in the mornings. We stayed during the beginning of week and didn't realize their restaurant would be closed during those days.
Fordele: what a charming beautiful great place to stay! perfect in every way! thank you for a wonderful weekend!
Fordele: Jason, our host, was fantastic/friendly/helpful; breakfasts were lovely; location was great; property was clean, charming, stylish.
Ulemper: No TV; restaurant wasn't open; needed a dresser or desk in the room to put things on. For well over $300/night, rooms were pretty bare-bones.
Fordele: Loved the porch!
Fordele: Very friendly & attentive staff made for a totally relaxing stay. We had a super comfortable room, the divine custom mattress ensured a perfect night's sleep. There are no televisions (much ...
Fordele: Loved everything about this place. Staff was wonderful, attentive and friendly. The hotel, grounds and room were quaint, comfortable and stylish. It was the perfect weekend getaway place four a single...
Ulemper: No dislikes at all.
Fordele: Large room and beautifully furnished. Cozy and warm.
Ulemper: Noise was a bit of an issue from other rooms, eg loud music at night and no one at the front desk to let know. I guess that is to be expected in a building of this age.
Fordele: Friendly staff cozy comfortable surroundings,Gracious spacious , Great food.
Ulemper: Wasn't anything I disliked.
Fordele: Great place with amazing staff, excellent breakfast and a very convenient location on Shelter Island - one of our favorite places to hang out.
Fordele: Nice assortment of choices. Excellent presentation.
Fordele: Friendly , welcoming staff. Cosy sitting room to further enjoy breakfast and evening wine events.
Fordele: Great get away spot. Staff very nice. Lovely breakfast. Very clean - bed comfy. Room small but well maintained property. Beautiful views. Nice pool.
Fordele: The bed was horrible
Ulemper: Mattress was poor
Fordele: The views
Ulemper: The room was disgusting. The rug was old and moldy; I refused to walk around barefoot.
Fordele: The setting of the hotel is wonderful, great sea views and beautiful sunsets. Breakfast and dinner on the outside veranda were fantastic. Shelter Island was the perfect location to unwind after a ...
Ulemper: Food and drink were expensive and there was no room service if you wanted something to eat after the main dinner sevice had finished. How about considering an all-inclusive option at the hotel or a ...
Fordele: Magnificent sunset views. Cycling around the island (hotel bikes are free for first hour). Helpful staff from all over the world.
Ulemper: Lobster roll on the dinner menu for $33. Not the best, and at that price :(
Fordele: The only thing this hotel has going for it is the location.
Ulemper: It is significantly overpriced for what it provides. The restaurant was closed for day 2 of our stay for an event that played ridiculously loud music until 11 pm. Not ideal when traveling with a 4 yr ...
Fordele: Great location
Ulemper: Prioritize private events over hotel guests. Kicked us out of pool to prep event. Loud music till 11 pm.
Fordele: The view is spectacular!! Friendly staff. Great breakfast included!! Friendly bartenders who make delicious drinks!! Private beach and great pool facilities!
Ulemper: Poor room lighting and only one outlet! You have to park up a hill and walk up and down. Lots of steps (no elevator).
Fordele: Bathrooms were very nice. Rooms well furnished. AC was strong. Great ice cream store literally next door. Pastries & fruit at breakfast were excellent but wished they had some hot foods.
Ulemper: We had 2 rooms. One room was fine- no issues. The other room (deluxe suite) had some issues. We did see lots of bugs and cobwebs in corners. Saw 2 tiny bugs hanging down from a cobweb over the ...
Fordele: The place itself looked beautiful on the outside. The chess board was a cute touch, but the experience was unbelievably disappointing.
Ulemper: We must have napoed for an hour each. The mattress was HORRENDOUS, we felt all the springs & it made terrible sounds when we tossed & turned. The family above us had kids running back & ...
Fordele: Location. Shelter Island has many interesting homes to see, and beautiful coastline.
Ulemper: The breakfast was bad. Consisted of coffee, pastry (good), and cold boiled egg. Everything self service like in a standard motel. Not what is expected for a b&b. Staff seldom on property.
Fordele: We liked that there was a little complementary breakfast included in the price. The croissants were extra fresh and tasty. We also liked that there were bycicles to use.