The Edition has become my favorite hotel in NYC. It's modern and clean without being trendy. It's luxury without being pretentious. The service was first class. The rooms were spacious, clean, and quiet. Even at $500-$600 a night it's a value. The restaurants and bars were fantastic. I think being across from Madison Park adds something unique. I highly recommend the Edition. Didn't love the elevator set up.
Room, Lobby Bar, Hotel Staff Complimentary coffee in lobby bar ends at 8am - too early!
Location is great - the art is amazing and the roof top terrace restaurant/ bar is top
Very Very cool. From a British viewpoint it is like Malmaison but taken to the next level and with the addition of 5 star service. The concierge are very good at getting you into those 'hard to book' restaurants. The private guests only rooftop bar is very nice.
unique, great location - very little street noise.
Valet took >45 minutes after being told 10-15 (I allowed 20). Had to request iron, wastes time. Tub drain was fully clogged and GROSS so water did not drain. Shower vent grate was FULL of GROSS dust + mold. Noise outside from traffic, garbage trucks + roof party letting out kept us awake ALL NIGHT, absurd! Sounded like windows on Lex.ave. were open, but they weren't, they're just inadequate!
The service, room, restaurant, location were excellent.
location is fabulous, rooftop bar was very nice. the room was very small.
The rooms were cute. Not to small. Stayed here for New Year's Eve. Wanted a bucket of ice for the room so my wife and I could keep a bottle of champagne cold. They actually charged us $5 for the bucket of ice. Not even Motel 6 charges for ice. Room was also very hot and a lot of noise from the street and hallway. Bed hard and uncomfortable.
Room set up Very poor service! I had water & juice poured over me during breakfast with no apologies! Tea was served without tea cup! Bathroom light was out for one day and not replaced. Laundry list was not provided despite repeated requests.
Staff were very helpful and always on hand. The room quality was very high - the recent refurbishment has really focussed on top end materials and furnishings and for a hotel in central New York, the room was of a good size. Its central location in NYC is very helpful to get uptown or downtown and its situation gives an unusually peaceful night sleep in such a busy city. The roof garden was very nice, as were the bars, but some of the hotel claims are overdone. Cocktails are expensive by the time you add on service and tax.
The staff was really friendly and helpful. The hotel design and atmosphere were great. The bed was very uncomfortable - really hard. I stay at alot of boutique / pricey hotels and this was the worst bed I've had.
the room and the position and the "edginess" of the hotel our first room (before we changed) only had a shower and not also a bath
God beliggenhed, fed tagterasse og ok værelser. Den ene dag var der ikke varmt vand som heller ikke blev løst så vi måtte bade i koldt vand! Vi fik dog kompenseret med 50 dollar så det var ok.
Personalet var meget hjælpsomt og venligt. Det lå godt, ikke så langt fra East Village og Greenwich og alligevel nær ved det centrale Manhattan. Desuden dejlig tagterrasse og gode fællesarealer. Morgenmad var lidt vel dyr, men god.
The room was pretty clean, comfortable and nicely decorated. The room was noisy--I could hear people in the hall and the room next to me. It could have been cleaner but over all it was not bad. I di not like the food in the restaurant "Olive's" it was too salty.
atmostphere was really fun. great buzz about the place every night. evening meal is amazing. cant think of anything at all
Loved this hotel. Friendly, helpful, small enough to not get lost in and just be a number. Food was excellent and service was helpful and immediate. Would stay here again definitely.
The location was superb. It was clean, quiet and very beautiful. None
Loved the room, they had all points I require to be totally happy. Luxury, cleanliness, location, friendly staff. Super!! Will love to stay their again. Thanks for the opportunity to try them out.
I absolutely loved this hotel. The location is very good, there are some great places to eat around there. Having room service was excellent, Good bar that served excellent cocktails. Would definitely stay again. Conciege were extremley helpful.
Fantastic location with excellent staff, our room was fantastic we received a free upgrade on check in. Hotel bar and restaurant are well worth visiting, the local suway is a 2 minute walk away.
The staff was friendly. The rooms were comfortable. The view was wonderful.
The staff is extremely helpful and friendly. The rooms are large, comfortable and beautifully decorated. And the location is perfect.
Everything. Manager, Chris was exceptional.
Good location. Some check in staff were terrific, some were condescending that I booked my room through kayak. I had to beg them to get my SPG preferred benefits. After I asked enough people, I got them, after hearing different stories about their policy.
Location is excellent and our room was very good. Hotel design is contemporary and modern. The door staff appeared disinterested in guests and there was generally a lack of friendly hospitality that you usually enjoy in the US. With the exception of the bar staff nobody smiled at us!
It had character There was a bar with a courtyard below my window, there was noise till 1:30 am. You could also hear the beds creaking!!!!
Afternoon tea, furnishings, nice staff. I could leave my luggage after check out until I picked it up late afternoon. No
Great location and staff was incredibly friendly. Rooms are rather small
Staff was extremely friendly and courteous.
Good prices. Clean and comfortable rooms which are a bit small but that is why you get the good price. Nice bathroom. Need a better sign on the street to help find the hotel. Block is not the nicest but lots of nice restaurants and other amenities nearby.
Great location and very hospitable and clean. It was a small space and when the air conditioner needed to be on, it would be incredibly loud.
It was very convenient to all the things we wanted to do. Small place with a friendly staff. I was able to park on the street all weekend. I expect to pay ~$300/night, but this wasn't up to the fee. The pillows are undersized by about 1/3. The room layout made it hard to get to the window side of the bed. There was no mini fridge. The nice rainfall shower head had no way for height-challenged people to change its position. The toilet seats are cheap plastic. No electric outlet on one side of the bed, inexcusable in the day of "I charge my phone while I sleep." The lighting scheme, involving use of your room card in a slot and a pad of push button switches, is inscrutable.
Meget centralt, venlig personale
Meget central beliggenhed = tæt på Subway. Et roligt og rent kvarter, og med dagligvarebutikker tæt på. Venligt personale. Præsentabelt udefra - men mørkt og dunkelt indvendig.
Hotellet var rent og pænt. Beliggenheden var super i forhold til The Village og offentligt transport (metro v. Union Square). Fint hotel til prisen. Ingen larm og venligt personale. Nej.
Værelse 316 - uden bad og toilet glimrende til prisen Lugt på gangareal 3.sal